In the wake of their first documentary's success, Peter and Sam seek a new case and settle on a stomach-churning mystery at a Washington high school.

Tyler Alvarezas Peter Maldonado
Griffin Gluckas Sam Ecklund
Jimmy Tatroas Dylan Maxwell
Calum Worthyas Alex Trimboli
Nathaniel J. Potvinas Trevor Gonzalez
Natalie Shershowas Kimberly Morris
Camille Ramseyas Mackenzie Wagner
Joyce Greenleafas Mrs. Rothacker
Bill Kottkampas Brian Wheeland
Kevin McManus
Matthew McManus
Tony Yacenda
Dan Lagana
Dan Perrault
Jaboukie Young-White