Schoolteacher Bertram Cates is arrested for teaching his students Darwin's theory of evolution. The case receives national attention and one of the newspaper reporters, E.K. Hornbeck, arranges to bring in renowned defense attorney and atheist Henry Drummond to defend Cates. The prosecutor, Matthew Brady is a former presidential candidate, famous evangelist, and old adversary of Drummond.

Spencer Tracyas Henry Drummond
Fredric Marchas Matthew Harrison Brady
Gene Kellyas E.K. Hornbeck
Dick Yorkas Bertram T. Cates
Donna Andersonas Rachel Brown
Harry Morganas Judge Mel
Claude Akinsas Rev. Jeremiah Brown
Elliott Reidas Prosecutor Tom Davenport
Paul Hartmanas Bailiff Mort Meeker
Philip Coolidgeas Mayor Jason Carter
Ernest Laszlo